Dove, Dogs, and Shotguns

July 8, 2009

Supreme Court Seeks to Protect Hunters

Filed under: Recent News — Tags: , — admin @ 8:41 am

From WCAX:

A new court ruling could ease prosecution of hunters who unintentionally wound or kill people. The Vermont Supreme Court has established the legal distinction between a tragic hunting accident and hunting criminal negligence that has already sent two hunters to prison with others awaiting trial.

Timothy Madden’s lawyer announced that Madden will be ready to be tried for involuntary manslaughter in October for shooting his pal David Jenkins while they were deer hunting in Milton. Police say Madden told them he thought Jenkins was a coyote and it was an accident.

Madden has rejected a plea deal for one year behind bars and chosen trial.

Five years ago Collin Viens became the first hunter ever sentenced to prison in Vermont, after he shot a farmer sitting in a tractor– not knowing the farmer was there. Viens got one year behind bars. He appealed claiming it was an accident, not a crime.

Two weeks ago the Vermont Supreme Court unanimously rejected Viens appeal. The court ruled that because Viens ignored the risk of causing the death or serious injury of all persons within gunshot range, the state was not even required to prove that he intentionally fired the rifle to prove criminal negligence.

“The Vermont Supreme Court is really clarifying that it’s not going to tolerate defenses that say, look, I didn’t mean to kill anybody. I wasn’t doing anything illegal,” explained Cheryl Hanna, a professor at Vt. Law School.

Hanna says the ruling established for the first time that hunters can be held criminally responsible for unintentionally wounding or killing others, even if they are breaking no other laws.

“Prior to this ruling it was often argued that you had to be engaged in doing something unlawful in order to be found guilty of involuntary manslaughter,” Hanna explained. “And the court says no, as long as you’re doing something that negligent, than any death or injury that results you can be held liable for.”For Timothy Madden that could mean up to 15 years behind bars if convicted of manslaughter at his trial in October. But prosecutors have been seeking one year in prison.

I think this is a good start for hunters. We don’t prosecute traffic accidents, other than establishing fault and writing a ticket, hunting accidents should be the same.

Time to RELOAD!

Dove, Dogs, & Shotguns

Dove, Dogs, & Shotguns

 

  • Share/Bookmark
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts
  • 6 New Texas Dove Leases If anyone has hunted these leases, feel free to leave a review on them. Thanks for posting them, and keep them coming. Below are the details: NAME OF LEASE: Carol Knutson EMAIL: info@muysecoranch.com CONTACT NAME: Carol CONTACT PHONE NUMBER: 830-363-4281 PREFERRED METHOD OF CONTACT: Either LOCATION INCLUDING CLOSEST CITY OR......
  • Father Charged in Hunting Accident From BullsandBeavers: St. Johnsbury, Vt. (AP) - A 44-year-old Lyndon Center man is being charged with manslaughter in the shooting death of his son while the two hunted for turkeys earlier this month. The Vermont State police say that Kevin Kadamus was processed Thursday at the state police barracks in......
  • Dove Hunting - It's More Than a Sport On our first trip to South Texas dove hunting my dad, brother, and I had a hair-brained idea to head south at 8:00 P.M.. The plan was to make the six hour drive, get four or five hours of sleep and hit the field for the morning hunt. Let's just......
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • Net Neutrality Pits Google, eBay, and Amazon, Against Telcos As telephone and digital companies continue to grow through mergers and acquisitions, network (''net'') neutrality, has become a contested area of law in the United States. Contoversial statements from Telco officials, as telephone networks appear to monopolize, has fueled the fire of independent Internet giants, such as Google, eBay,......
  • School and State at Ends over Gun Decision The decision was made less than a day before the East Wake High School (North Carolina) marksmanship team was set to face off in a statewide shooting competition. At the behest of one of the principals of East Wake, along with the superintendent, the school team was barred from competing......
  • Lemon Law Lawyer California lemon law lawyer William Krieg recalls a lemon car case where a consumer turned in a defective 1997 Ford Taurus with transmission problems. The dealership was quick to offer him $1,500 toward the purchase of a new car, even though the consumer was entitled to a free replacement vehicle,......

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress